Global Systemic Risk GMES Analysis — User Guide
See which banks would need emergency capital and how much, ranked by systemic importance
Contents
Page Overview
Essential Concepts
Navigation Guide
Data Interpretation
Practical Applications
Understanding Data
Troubleshooting
Tips & Best Practices
Essential Concepts
These terms appear in the rankings table columns and the time series chart. Understanding them will help you interpret the data:
SRISK (Systemic Risk)
The dollar amount a bank would need in emergency capital during a crisis. Calculated from the bank's size, leverage, and market sensitivity. Displayed in millions of dollars.
Why it matters: Banks with the highest SRISK values are the ones most likely to need bailouts during financial crises. These are the institutions regulators watch most closely.
SRISK%
A bank's share of the total systemic risk in the financial system. If a bank has 15% SRISK%, it would account for 15% of total emergency capital needed during a crisis.
Why it matters: Identifies which banks dominate systemic risk. A system where 5 banks account for 80% of SRISK% is more fragile than one where risk is spread across many institutions.
LRMES (Long-Run Marginal Expected Shortfall)
How much of a bank's stock value would be lost if the market dropped by the selected threshold over six months. Expressed as a percentage. A 60% LRMES means the bank would lose 60% of its market value.
Why it matters: High LRMES indicates the firm would experience larger equity losses than the market during a crisis. This amplification effect is a key input into SRISK calculations.
Beta (Market Sensitivity)
How much a bank's stock moves relative to the market. A beta of 1.5 means if the market moves 1%, the bank's stock typically moves 1.5% in the same direction.
Why it matters: High-beta banks amplify market movements. They gain more in bull markets but lose more in bear markets, contributing to financial system volatility.
Correlation (Cor)
How closely a bank's stock moves with the overall market, from 0 (no relationship) to 1 (moves perfectly together). Most banks show correlation between 0.5 and 0.9.
Why it matters: High correlation means the bank provides little diversification benefit. During crises, correlations typically spike toward 1, making diversification less effective when you need it most.
Volatility (Vol)
The annualized standard deviation of returns. A 30% volatility means that over a year, returns typically fall within about plus or minus 30% of the expected return roughly 68% of the time, assuming returns approximately follow a normal distribution.
Why it matters: Higher volatility means more uncertainty about the bank's value. Combined with high leverage, it makes banks more vulnerable to sudden capital shortfalls.
Leverage (Lvg)
Quasi-leverage: total assets divided by market equity. Leverage of 15 means the bank has $15 of assets for every $1 of market equity. Because V-Lab uses market equity (not book equity), leverage changes daily as stock prices move.
Why it matters: High leverage amplifies both gains and losses. A bank with 20x leverage loses all its equity if asset values drop just 5%.
Stressed Leverage (Stressed Lvg)
Projected leverage after the bank suffers crisis losses captured by LRMES. If a bank starts at 15x leverage and loses 60% of equity (LRMES of 60%), its stressed leverage would be 37.5x because the same debt is now backed by only 40% of the original equity.
Why it matters: Shows how bad things would get during a crisis. Banks that start with high leverage and high LRMES can see stressed leverage explode to dangerous levels.
Data Interpretation
Reading the Rankings Table
The rankings table shows which banks pose the greatest systemic risk. Banks near the top have the highest SRISK values and would need the most emergency capital during a crisis.
What Drives High SRISK
Three factors combine to determine a bank's SRISK:
- Size
Larger banks naturally have higher SRISK because their failure would require more capital to address. A $2 trillion bank failing matters more than a $20 billion bank.
- Leverage (Lvg Column)
Banks with high leverage have less equity cushion. Look at the Lvg column: banks above 20x are highly leveraged. These banks lose proportionally more equity in downturns.
- Market Sensitivity (LRMES Column)
Banks with high LRMES fall harder than the market. An LRMES of 80% means the bank loses 80% of its value when the market falls by the selected threshold. These banks amplify crises.
What the Numbers Mean
- Positive SRISK
The bank would need this much emergency capital during a crisis. A bank with $50B SRISK would need $50 billion in new capital (or bailout) to remain solvent.
- Negative SRISK (or Not Listed)
The bank would still have adequate capital after absorbing crisis losses. These banks are relatively safer. They don't appear in the positive-only rankings but may appear in full data downloads.
- SRISK% (First Column After Name)
Shows this bank's share of total system risk with a heat-mapped red background for quick visual comparison. If the top 5 banks account for 50% of total SRISK%, the system is heavily concentrated. Watch for concentration patterns.
Practical Applications
Finding Specific Banks
Use the search box (magnifying glass icon) above the rankings table to find banks by name or ticker. Type part of the name or ticker and the table filters instantly. Use this when you're looking for a specific institution rather than browsing rankings.
Comparing Banks Over Time
Click 'View changes' above the rankings table. Two date pickers appear. The table then shows SRISK on each date, the difference, and a decomposition showing how much of the change came from debt, equity, or LRMES. Delta columns use diverging red-blue cell backgrounds (light blue for negative changes, light red for positive) for quick visual scanning. This helps you understand whether rising risk is due to increased borrowing, falling stock prices, or heightened market sensitivity.
Downloading Data
After logging in, two download options are available. 'DOWNLOAD DATASET DATA' exports the full rankings table (large file) with a README explaining all fields; this always uses default parameters regardless of your page settings. 'DOWNLOAD GRAPH DATA' exports only the time series currently displayed in the chart, using whatever custom parameters you've set on the page.
Understanding Data
How the Data Is Calculated
SRISK combines two data sources: daily stock prices (for market-based risk measures) and quarterly balance sheets (for leverage calculations).
- Update Schedule
Rankings are recalculated every Saturday morning. The 'Last Updated' date in the header shows when the current data was calculated. Between updates, values remain fixed even as markets move.
- Why 40% Default?
The 40% market decline matches the severity of the 2008-2009 financial crisis. This is not a prediction; it is a stress test asking 'what if 2008 happened again?' You can adjust this to model milder or more severe scenarios.
Understanding the Model Types
- MES (Dynamic MES for US Financials)
Covers US financial institutions using the S&P 500 as the market index. Uses Dynamic Conditional Beta with analytical LRMES calculation that updates daily. The standard choice for routine monitoring of US banks.
- MESSIM (Simulation-Based MES)
Covers US financial institutions using Monte Carlo simulation with 10,000 scenarios. More accurate tail risk estimation but updates weekly rather than daily. Crisis threshold fixed at 40% due to simulation complexity. Best for detailed tail risk analysis.
- GMES and DMES (Global and Domestic)
GMES covers worldwide institutions using each bank's local market index with asynchronous trading adjustments for different time zones. DMES analyzes banks within a single country using that country's domestic index. Both use Dynamic Conditional Beta with daily updates.
Troubleshooting
Common Questions
Why did a bank's SRISK jump dramatically between weeks?
SRISK can jump for two reasons. First, stock price changes: when a bank's stock drops, its market value falls and leverage rises (same debt, less equity), causing SRISK to spike. Second, balance sheet updates: when new quarterly data is released, changes in debt levels or book equity can shift SRISK even if the stock price is stable. Check both the stock chart and whether the jump coincides with quarterly reporting dates.
Why doesn't Bank X appear in the rankings?
Banks with negative SRISK (adequate capital even after crisis losses) do appear in the table, but if sorted by SRISK descending (the default), they will be at the bottom. Scroll down, change the sort order, or use the search box to find them by name or ticker. Also check that you have the correct region and country filters selected.
Why is there no time series data for a particular bank?
Time series require sufficient historical data. Recently listed banks, banks that changed names or merged, or thinly traded stocks may have gaps. The chart shows whatever data is available; missing periods appear as gaps in the line.
Why are European and US banks calculated differently?
European banks report under IFRS accounting standards; US banks use GAAP. Due to differences in how assets are measured, a 5.5% capital ratio under IFRS is economically equivalent to 8% under GAAP. V-Lab applies the appropriate ratio by region automatically (Europe defaults to 5.5%, all other regions to 8%). In Global view, use the 'Customize' button to edit per-region capital requirements, or the 'Reset' button to restore defaults.
Understanding the Limitations
- What SRISK Doesn't Capture
SRISK measures expected capital shortfall in a crisis, not probability of failure. High SRISK does not mean a bank is likely to fail. It means the bank would need significant capital if a crisis occurred. Conversely, low SRISK doesn't guarantee safety, as banks can fail for non-market reasons (fraud, operational risks) not captured in stock prices.
- Quarterly vs. Daily Data
V-Lab uses quasi-leverage, which combines market equity (updated daily) with balance sheet debt (updated quarterly). So leverage changes daily as stock prices move, but the debt component only updates with new quarterly filings. A bank's reported leverage here may differ from its book leverage.
- Correlation During Crises
Correlations estimated from normal periods may understate how banks move together during crises. The model uses dynamic correlation estimates that adapt, but extreme events can still exceed model expectations.
Frequently Asked Technical Questions
How is beta estimated? What time period is used?
Beta is estimated using all available daily returns from 2000 to the present. There is no rolling window. Instead, more recent observations are weighted more heavily through the GARCH-DCC model. This balances long history with responsiveness to recent changes.
Can I download the balance sheet data used in calculations?
No. The underlying balance sheet data comes from third-party providers with distribution restrictions. We can describe our data sources and methodology for research purposes, but cannot share raw financial statement data. The SRISK calculations themselves are available for download.
How do I download data for my research?
Log in to V-Lab (free registration). 'DOWNLOAD DATASET DATA' gives you the full rankings table (large file) with a README; this always uses default parameters regardless of page settings. 'DOWNLOAD GRAPH DATA' exports only the currently displayed time series using your custom parameter settings. For bulk or API access, contact the V-Lab team through the contact form.
Tips & Best Practices
Quick Start: First 60 Seconds
- 1. Check the Header
Look at the total capital shortfall number at the top. This is the total bailout cost if a crisis hit today. Note whether it seems high relative to historical values.
- 2. Scan the Top of the Rankings Table
The banks at the top have the highest SRISK. Note the names: these are the most systemically important. Look at the SRISK% column to see how much of total risk each bank represents.
- 3. Click a Bank to See Its History
Select any bank in the rankings. The time series chart expands and shows that bank's SRISK over time. Look for trends: is risk rising or falling? Were there spikes during past crises?
- 4. Sort by Different Columns
Sort by LRMES to see which banks are most market-sensitive. Sort by Lvg to see most leveraged. Compare the different rankings to understand what drives each bank's risk.
- 5. Test Different Scenarios
Change the crisis threshold from 40% to 50% and watch the total shortfall increase. This shows how sensitive the system is to crisis severity.
Tips for Effective Analysis
- Watch for Changes Over Time
Use the 'View changes' toggle to compare two dates. Banks with rapidly increasing SRISK may be emerging risks even if their current level isn't the highest.
- Use Multiple Metrics
Don't rely on SRISK alone. A bank with high SRISK but low LRMES is large and leveraged but stable. A bank with high LRMES is volatile even if current SRISK is moderate.
- Check Concentration
Add up SRISK% for the top 5 banks. If they account for 50%+ of total risk, the system is concentrated. Distributed risk (many banks each with small shares) is generally safer.
- Visit V-Lab's Welcome Page for Context
The Analysis page shows individual banks; the Welcome page shows country totals and comparisons. Use both together. To navigate to the Welcome page, click the previous entry in the breadcrumbs at the top of the page (below the navigation bar). High country totals might be driven by one dominant bank or many smaller ones.
Was this page helpful?